After the fire, no one believes the girls when they insist that they saw Ali. "A" sends Emily to Lancaster, where she discovers that an Amish girl named Leah disappeared around the time of Ali's death. Emily also discovers that Darren Wilden had been Amish and left the community, and she soon comes to believe that he killed Leah. Thinking that Ali's ghost is trying to tell her something, Aria goes to a séance; she learns nothing, but meets Noel Kahn. She initially does not trust him but later changes her mind, kissing him after he comes to her defense at a party. Aria sees another medium, who produces a message in Ali's handwriting that asserts that Ali killed herself. Hanna's father sends her to a clinic to prevent her eating disorder from reappearing due to stress from the Ali situation, and to cure her Posttraumatic stress disorder. Hanna befriends another patient named Iris, who later abandons her after another patient reveals Hanna's scandalous past to everyone at the clinic. Hanna dreams about Ali, who leads her to suspect that Iris had something to do with Ali's death. "A" sends Spencer messages which make her suspicious of her mother; Spencer learns that at one point her father had been having an affair with Ali's mother. Spencer realizes the possibility that Ali and Jason are her half-siblings, and is led to believe that her mother may have killed Ali because of it. Spencer confronts her parents, but her mother is shocked to hear about the affair for the first time. Aria, Spencer, Emily, and Hanna are all arrested for Ali's murder; together in a jail cell, they realize that "A" has tricked each of them into believing someone else killed Ali.