Vin Gonzales has been released from prison and is drinking coffee in a diner. There, he sees a small memorial for Oksana, Rhino's wife. He tells the waitress that he gives thanks to his "higher power" for new beginnings.

In an alley, Peter and Carlie is gathering things for Harry's going away party. Harry and his son Stanley are moving away for safety reasons. Carlie is still angry at Peter for having her worried during the event of Lily's baby. Later, Peter talks to Michelle about meeting Vin in the diner. Although Peter promises to get there in time, he soon sees Overdrive kidnapping Terri Hilman, the daughter of a powerful socialite. Since his costume is dirty after the battle with Doctor Octopus, Peter is forced to use a Halloween Spider-Man costume. Overdrive transforms the limousine he is driving into a copy of the Spider-Mobile. He then shoots Peter with webs, pinning him into a wall. However, Peter manages to take Overdrive out from the car and leave him hanging for the police. However, since he is still stuck to the wall, Peter has to take out his clothes to swing away, and Hilman threatens to sue Spider-Man.

At the diner, Michelle apologizes to Vin for getting late, and finds that Peter got before her. There, they talk about what has happened after Vin was sent to prison. Later, Vin goest to the police departmant, where many cops still hate him. Vin finds Carlie and tells her that he needs her to listen to what he is saying.

At the costume party in Aunt May's house, everyone is in costumes. Peter goes dressed as J. Jonah Jameson, Mary Jane as Jackpot, Flash Thompson as Spider-Man in a wheelchair, Carlie as Black Cat, Harry and his son Stanley as Doctor Octopus and Vin as a prisoner. Vin finds Harry and tells him that his father wanted Vin tell Harry to take care of Stanley. He reveals to Harry that Norman Osborn is his higher power. Carlie tells Peter that although she apologizes for making a scene the other day, she still means what she said. Peter goes to talk with Mary Jane, who tells him that Carlie went to ask advice from her about going out with Peter. Mary Jane said to Carlie that Peter has the right to be happy. Mary Jane tells Peter that he shouldn't be afraid of dating someone just because Spider-Man will interfere in the relationship. Peter then finds Carlie and asks if she would be his girlfriend. Carlie smiles and the two kiss.